Experts Explain How Sunscreen Really Works—and Why Better Ones May Be Coming Soon

Sunscreen tin beryllium confounding. Some formulations are heavy and chalky, others are clear and “lightweight,” immoderate travel arsenic a lotion, others arsenic sprays, sticks and gels. Some are branded “broad spectrum” and “water resistant." And past there’s nan mobility of SPF—how precocious is precocious enough?

Ahead of Memorial Day, nan unofficial commencement to summer, Scientific American said pinch dermatology and cosmetic chemistry researchers astir nan subject of sunscreen: really it works, really to usage it properly, and really formulations successful nan U.S. could beryllium improved—and sooner than you think.

How sunscreen protects you from nan sun

On supporting subject journalism

If you're enjoying this article, see supporting our award-winning publicity by subscribing. By purchasing a subscription you are helping to guarantee nan early of impactful stories astir nan discoveries and ideas shaping our world today.

Let’s commencement pinch really sunscreen works. Ultraviolet (UV) radiation from nan sun tin origin tegument crab by damaging nan DNA successful our tegument cells arsenic good arsenic origin premature tegument aging and wrinkles. Sunscreen typically protects our skin from those harmful rays successful 2 ways: by blocking UV ray aliases by absorbing it (or both).

“Mineral” aliases “physical” sunscreens—formulations made pinch zinc oxide and titanium dioxide—are thought to beryllium UV blockers, though research shows they tin besides sorb UV light, too. They enactment arsenic nanoparticle-size “mirrors” to bespeak UV radiation and visible light, says David Fisher, a professor successful nan section of Dermatology astatine Harvard Medical School and a expert astatine Massachusetts General Hospital. That’s besides why they thin to beryllium pasty achromatic successful color.

“Chemical” sunscreens are chiefly UV absorbers. “Chemical sunscreens are fundamentally utilizing molecules that tin sorb different wavelengths wrong nan UV information of nan spectrum,” Fisher explains. Then they person nan UV ray into heat. These sunscreens are typically transparent, and don’t time off a achromatic sheen connected nan skin, says Kerry Hanson, a investigation chemist astatine nan University of California, Riverside.

SPF, aliases “sun protection factor” measures a sunscreen’s expertise to protect you from burning. But here’s nan rub—it specifically measures protection from UVB light, nan portion of nan UV spectrum pinch a wavelength of betwixt 280 and 315 nanometers. While UVB vulnerability has immoderate benefits—it immunodeficiency successful nan synthesis of Vitamin D, for instance—it tin besides origin sunburn, redness and inflammation, Fisher says.

For years, sunscreen manufacturers person prioritized products that protect against UVB. Scientists now believe that UVA—ultraviolet ray pinch wavelengths betwixt 315 and 400 nanometers—can raise nan consequence of tegument cancer, too. That consequence isn’t captured by a metric for illustration SPF. If your sunscreen protects against UVB but not UVA, it whitethorn beryllium protecting you from getting burnt but still putting you astatine consequence from nan sun’s harmful rays, Fisher says.

There is different way, however. Sunscreens branded arsenic “broad spectrum” successful mentation protect from some UVB and UVA light. But location isn’t an SPF-like measurement for UVA successful nan U.S., which intends it tin beryllium difficult to cognize really overmuch UVA protection a “broad spectrum” sunscreen whitethorn provide, Fisher says.

Other regions of nan world, including Asia and Europe, usage a metric called UVA-PF, aliases “UVA protection factor” which does measurement protection against UVA, say, pinch a standing standard specified arsenic PA+ to PA++++, explains AJ Addae, a cosmetic intelligence and a PhD campaigner astatine nan University of California, Los Angeles—but UVA-PF is not thing nan U.S. Food and Drug administration, which oversees sunscreen, requires aliases regulates.

How U.S. sunscreen formulations are changing

In caller years, wellness advocates and user protection groups person raised immoderate information concerns astir definite ingredients successful immoderate sunscreens. Spray-on sun protection tin beryllium flammable; others person been recalled for contamination pinch benzene, a carcinogen, nan U.S. Food and Drug Administration notes. Research besides suggests that immoderate chemic sunscreen ingredients whitethorn damage marine life, specified arsenic coral reefs.

In 2019, nan FDA released a study showing that definite molecules successful chemic sunscreens—such arsenic avobenzone, ecamsule, octocrylene and oxybenzone—may beryllium absorbed into nan bloodstream, calling for further investigation. Experts told Scientific American that it’s still unclear what, if any, consequence those chemicals whitethorn airs to health.

“Insufficient information does not mean that’s a conclusion by america that they’re unsafe,” Theresa Michele, past nan head of nan FDA's Office of Nonprescription Drugs, told Scientific American successful 2023. “It conscionable intends we’re requesting further data.”

As that investigation continues, wellness experts stress that nan consequence of tegument crab is real—and accent nan value of wearing sunscreen to protect against it.

How to take nan champion sunscreen

The reply to this is simpler than you mightiness think.

“The champion sunscreen is nan sunscreen that you will wear,” Addae says. She recommends uncovering a pick aliases lotion of astatine slightest SPF 30 pinch a look and consciousness that you like. “If you don't for illustration wearing it, you're not going to deterioration it,” she says. Addae is developing zinc oxide sunscreens that don’t time off arsenic overmuch of a achromatic gloomy by changing nan style of nan chemical’s particle structure, an advancement which whitethorn beryllium peculiarly beneficial for group pinch darker tegument tones.

If you’re going to nan formation aliases doing an activity that makes you sweat, Hanson recommends a water-resistant, broad-spectrum sunscreen for nan top protection. Apply it liberally—and reapply often, she says: To meet intended protection levels, nan mean American needs astir a shot glass-worth of sunscreen to screen their full body. “Your extremity is to make a bully movie arsenic if it’s latex paint,” she says.

Sunscreens disposable successful different parts of nan world specified arsenic Europe and Asia whitethorn connection a wider assortment of progressive ingredients. That’s because nan U.S. FDA regulates sunscreens arsenic a drug, which carries strict rules, alternatively of arsenic a cosmetic, Hanson says. Last year, nan FDA proposed allowing a caller constituent called bemotrizinol—commonly recovered successful Asian and European sunscreens—to beryllium utilized successful nan U.S. If approved, it’d beryllium nan first caller ingredient to beryllium allowed successful sunscreen since 1999.

And, of course, sunscreen isn’t nan only measurement to protect yourself from nan sun. Avoiding highest sunlight hours, and wearing hats, clothing, and sticking to nan shadiness are safe and effective ways to trim your consequence of harmful sun exposure, Fisher says. “I cannot overemphasize nan worth of beingness intends of sun protection,” he adds.